Nothing is stupid about this

Fundraising for a food bank during a recession is only marginally more difficult than falling off a log – when you do it right.

Written by
Jeff Brooks
Added
May 14, 2013

I guess that’s just too boring for some people, like the creative agency that sunk its claws into the Rhode Island Community Food Bank

These guys came up with a way to brand hunger by pointing out that the hungry have nothing to eat. The centrepiece of the campaign is empty cans, labelled ‘Nothing’, that people can buy for $2.99. So far, so good, and if they’d stopped there they might have had an interesting alternative fundraising and awareness effort. But we’re talking about an ad agency so the approach quickly went off the rails. Here’s how the Nothing.org website explains it:

Each day, thousands of hungry Rhode Islanders eat nothing. By turning nothing into a product you can buy, we're going to change that.

If you’re noticing a heavy odour of self-reference in the above sentence you’ve found the problem. These guys were so impressed with their clever packaging of hunger they couldn’t stop talking about it. Here’s how a spokesperson from the agency explained the work:

‘[People in their thirties] can afford to donate, but they prefer to make donations to solve finite problems: to build a wing for a hospital, a playground for a school. Things like a cure for cancer or an end to hunger are intangible.’

Good point. That’s not just people in their thirties, that’s everyone. But the real question somebody should have asked was: if you realise people prefer to give to tangible causes, why did you create an abstraction about hunger? Because that’s exactly what this campaign is. Rather than talk about people who are hungry and the food they need – which is a very powerful and proven way to motivate people to give to food banks – they created a ‘product’ that symbolises the issue of hunger.

And then, in typical ad agency fashion, they fumbled in several other key ways that nobody who does fundraising would ever do. The ‘give’ link on the Nothing.org website is hard to find, the giving form has some kind of programming error that renders it unusable and, as if they’re allergic to actually asking for a gift, check out what the ask itself looks like, opposite. There are more design and writing problems with this ask alone than we have room to uncover here, so I won’t even get started.

And to top it all, there’s this goofy use of outdoor advertising for the campaign. The billboards say:

Nothing can end hunger in Rhode Island.

Okay, a well-built double meaning can sometimes add resonance and memorability to a slogan or call to action. But when the second meaning is the exact opposite of what you’re saying it isn’t working.

There are some cool things about the campaign. Selling the empty cans of ‘Nothing’ at grocery stores may generate revenue. And if the cans themselves include compelling copy and response options they may even bring in donors (but I have a sneaking suspicion that this was neglected). And some of the videos are very touching.

In what I’m sure is the campaign’s greatest triumph, it was written up in the New York Times: ‘Campaign Offer Plenty of Nothing’. I’ll leave that for you to decide…

About the author: Jeff Brooks

Jeff Brooks

Jeff Brooks, creative director at TrueSense Marketing, has served the nonprofit community for more than 20 years, working as a writer and creative director on behalf of a variety of organisations, including CARE, Bible League International, World Vision, Feeding America, World Relief and dozens of urban rescue missions and Salvation Army divisions. He blogs at Future Fundraising Now, podcasts at Fundraising is Beautiful and is a columnist forFundraising Successmagazine. In previous careers, he's been an English teacher and a classical musician. He lives in Seattle in the USA.

Recent Articles

NSPCC’s Full Stop campaign - a fundraising triumph. Part five: recognition and consolidation

The Full Stop appeal itself was only one chapter in the story of this groundbreaking campaign, as Giles Pegram reveals how the NSPCC ensured its donors were properly recognised and its success in the appeal was consolidated.

Read more

SOFII’s lightbulb moments - latest videos

Discover more exciting and simple ideas in next four videos of the new series from SOFII: 32 lightbulb moments that will transform your fundraising.

Read more

What’s the golden thread that unites us?

There were so many great and inspirational ideas shared at I Wish I'd Thought Of That 2018. Which of these will inspire you to transform your fundraising?

Read more

How to bring feminism into your fundraising

Emily Collins-Ellis and Rachel Stephenson Sheff demonstrate that feminism needs to be brought into fundraising, not just because it's the right thing to do, but because it will improve that fundraising and benefit your organisation.

Read more

NSPCC’s Full Stop campaign - a fundraising triumph. Part four: final challenges

In part four of the chronicle of the NSPCC’s Full Stop campaign, Giles Pegram CBE shares how the organisation responded to their massive appeal and broke a UK record.

Read more

Also in Categories