Doing good with Dundee cakes

If fundrais­ing was left to vil­lage fetes, the vol­un­tary sec­tor would be a nicer, if poor­er, place.

Written by
George Smith
Added
April 07, 2014
Village fetes are part of the world of idyllic fundraising.

No sooner had I come back from doing my duty at the village school’s summer fete when the bell rang. It was the good Doctor Wood, a neighbour, collecting for the lifeboats. Another couple of pounds changed hands, bringing the afternoon’s philanthropy to nearly a tenner. I had acquired a tin of pink salmon in the tombola, a Dundee cake, half a yard of bedding plants and three RNLI stickers from Doctor Wood. This must have been about par for the flashier donors around here.

Among his spoils from the village fete, George had a Dundee cake and some bedding plants.

Say there’s a hundred such plutocrats in the village and reckon that there must have been several hundred more contributing at a lower level. That’s a couple of thousand pounds raised on Saturday afternoon in a small Kentish village. Repeat it several times a year (and we do) and the statistics begin to get awesome. Doctor Wood will be back in a week or two for Help the Aged and the church flower festival is next weekend. I forgot to mention that the Saturday morning shopping trip in our local market town featured a trad jazz band outside Boots and the young mums collecting for the local playgroup. Add another couple of quid.

Not that we remain unmoved between house-to-house collections and special events (did I mention that the Fun Run was last weekend?) judging by the car stickers around here, WWF has a 50 per cent penetration of all households and Christian Aid something similar from May to September. Our admirable Women’s Institute is forever passing radical resolutions and ending the weekly sessions with a collection for something or other. Let it not be said that our wealth is other than modestly recycled by the week.

A Greenpeace sticker in the back of the family car and a subscription to The Guardian made the Smith family bohemian.

Of course, it is painless. It takes a misanthrope to avoid the jollity at the school fete and the chance to gossip with neighbours. Or to emerge without a Dundee cake and bedding plants. It takes a surly temperament to walk eyes down past the playgroup mums. And saying no to Doctor Wood would risk moral obloquy on a scale that would cause a frisson every time you walked into the village shop.

We all know each other, you see. That was Wendy behind the cake stall at the fete. The bedding plants are donated by Mrs Price. Doctor Wood marks the footpaths for us. I am known to be bohemian because of the greenpeace sticker in the back of the Fiat and as the sole reader of The Guardian in the village.

This is idyllic fundraising for it must extract something like ten thousand pounds annually from a village of seven hundred souls by way of collective effort. Add in the private and discreet giving and you can fairly double or treble that sum. Call it twenty-five thousand pounds a year from those seven hundred people; thirty-five pounds a head.

Is the citizenry of gentrified London good for thirty-five quid a year?

It is a sum that leaves us ahead of the latest CAF statistics for charity giving. If it were touted as an index of village philanthropy, we would be lauded in the local press as a citadel of decency and niceness. We are nothing of the sort, of course; we are merely buying Wendy’s Dundee cakes and passing the time of day with Doctor Wood. Our giving forms a sort of licence to live here. In any sense of social responsibility, thirty-five pounds a head is not good enough.

But how do you make the difference? Doctor Wood is never going to demand a fiver for his RNLI stickers and there is a common understanding that a Dundee cake has its rightful price. Yet, I yearn for our beleaguered village school to ask those of us who can afford it to give lots more. But to provoke them to do so would be seen as a breach of local taste. I have actually offered my services in this mode. I was told that it would upset people. I know what they mean, for the intervention of full-blooded fundraising into a community so genuinely decent and altruistic would be alien and aberrant.

So, we shall remain under-achievers, giving less that we could because the manner of our giving is so pleasant. Switch the geographic coordinates and you get the scale of the problem. In the South London streets that I left to move here, there would be no Doctor Wood to collect and not many doors that would open if he did. There are few fun runs around Brixton and trade in bedding plants is scant. The indices of wealth are probably similar but even our cost apparatus of giving is largely absent. Is the citizenry of yuppified Inner London good for thirty-five pounds a year?

Our giving, like so much else in the UK, is imprisoned by our social structures, our national suspicion of change and virility, our acquiescence in the minimal gesture. It will take a bold charity to challenge these things And I am far from convinced that such boldness would be fruitful. As my local head teacher said, we don’t want to upset people. 

About the author: George Smith

George Smith

The late George Smith (he/him) wrote his first fundraising ad for Oxfam in 1962. In his twenties he was appointed European coordinator for a major-league American advertising agency and, in contrast, was elected as a local councillor in an inner-London borough. He formed the Smith Bundy direct marketing agency in 1973 and served as chief executive for 20 years. During those two decades his copywriting skills were applied to many diverse commercial direct marketing clients, yet fundraising was always a specialism. In 1990 he was awarded the UK’s DMA Gold Award for work on Greenpeace.

Between 1987 and 1993 George was chief executive of the International Fund Raising Group, responsible for the celebrated Noordwijkerhout conference and a growing number of events around the world. He was also a director of Burnett Associates Limited. His monthly articles in Britain’s Direct Response magazine were published in 1987 as a collection called By George. He became chairman of the UK’s Institute of Direct Marketing (IDM) in 1997 and is an honorary fellow both of the IDM and the Chartered Institute of Fundraising.

George Smith also wrote Asking ProperlyTiny Essentials of Writing for Fundraising and Up Smith Creek.

A note from SOFII: These articles were first published in a different era. They may contain words or themes that today we find inappropriate. SOFII has preserved the copy in our archive, without editing, in order to offer a true representation of the author’s contributions at the time.

Recent Articles

The Wizard of Oz – key advice for legacy fundraisers

Join Chris Millward as he steps inside a classic film for take a walk along the ‘yellow brick road’. While doing so, he’ll take you on a journey towards legacy fundraising success.

Read more

Six essential steps to improving your supporter experience

Creating an excellent supporter experience is a marathon, not a sprint. In this article, you will find some useful top tips for giving supporters the best experience possible.

Read more

The key to a successful corporate partnership – finding the ‘sweet spot’

What can you do to connect with corporate partners and ensure a long and healthy relationship? In this article, Keith Kibirango celebrates a partnership he admires, and explains why it took a bit of time (and a lot of careful collaboration) to get it just right.  

Read more

How to write for your most generous eyes and hands

Want to make sure your best givers can physically read what you write? Need to defend why you make some of the copy and design choices you do? Then don’t miss Lisa Sargent’s latest tips on making your fundraising communications accessible to older donors. 

Read more

SolarAid: Lighting the way

Richard Turner, director of fundraising at SolarAid, highlights how the charity took a strategic phased approach to raising £1 million over three years. He also includes useful top tips to help you secure funding for your next new idea.

Read more

Also in Categories