Pre­tenders to the Stew­ard Throne

Stew­ard­ship is the new buzz­word. Every­one is talk­ing about it. But it rais­es more ques­tions than it answers.

Written by
Gordon Michie
Added
June 02, 2010
All 19 pages of Pretenders to the Steward Throne are now available free to SOFII users.

This White Paper sets out to clarify some of the confusions around the term stewardship, exploring:

  • Different notions of stewardship.
  • The differences between stewardship, donor care and relationship fundraising.
  • US notions of stewardship as they relate to planned giving.
  • Different types of fundraising stewardship – including the idea of ‘Third Level Stewardship’ which sits above and encompasses relationship fundraising and is a notion of stewardship that is not yet practised or aspired to by British fundraisers.

The White Paper then identifies nine barriers to the adoption and take-up of stewardship among UK charities:

  • What does stewardship actually mean?
  • British, or American-style stewardship?
  • There is no common understanding of stewardship in a fundraising context.
  • Bandwagon jumping.
  • Low standards of donor care could undermine stewardship.
  • Measurement – KPIs (key performance indicators) and benchmarks are needed to assess the impact of stewardship.
  • Is stewardship a means or an end?
  • Training/CPD issues.
  • Lack of will for stewardship to succeed.

Finally, this White Paper concludes by calling on the Institute of Fundraising to set up a working party to develop a code of practice on fundraising stewardship that will introduce a definition of stewardship that can be used as a benchmark for all fundraisers.

To read the full white paper download the PDF.

Notes

The opinions expressed in this article and this download belong to the author and are not necessarily shared by SOFII.—SOFII editors

About the author: Gordon Michie

Gordon Michie is the Development Director at Relationship Marketing Limited

Recent Articles

Can fundraisers tell the difference between AI and human-written thank you letters?

Surprising survey results show that AI letters were rated higher by fundraisers than human-written letters. 

Read more

A medida que los donantes jóvenes empiezan a participar más, ¿están las organizaciones preparadas para ellos?

Las personas jóvenes están listas para apoyar a las organizaciones, pero la forma en la que te comunicas con ellas puede marcar una gran diferencia en que elijan o no tu causa. En este artículo, Anjali Bewtra de Blue State, comparte qué tomar en cuenta al comunicarse con este público, junto con ejemplos de entidades que ya lo están haciendo bien.

Read more

Gigging for a good cause – War Child’s BRITs Week fundraising

Oscar Lester looks at charity concerts and celebrates one of the best – War Child’s annual collaboration with the BRIT Awards. He explains how BRITs Week leverages the timeless appeal of live music, and generates thousands of pounds every year for children impacted by war and conflict

Read more

Why should you structure legacy fundraising content around pledger stories?

When it comes to legacy fundraising, the research is clear. Effective legacy content should be structured around the stories of your living pledgers.

Read more

Key fundraising insights for 2026

Blue State are back with their Giving Behaviours Tracker. This time they asked 2,010 people in the UK about their giving habits – including what motivates them to give and what holds them back. Click to read an overview, then down­load the full report to explore the data further.

Read more

Also in Categories