A medieval ‘course’ in writing an appeal

Here at SOFII, we love to learn about fundraising’s exceptional past. Luckily, our good friend Mark Phillips from Bluefrog Fundraising is on hand once again to share the remarkable story of a fundraising ‘course’ from medieval times.

Written by
Mark Phillips
Added
February 11, 2021

NB: this article first appeared on Mark’s blog Queer Ideas here. We are very grateful to Mark for letting us reproduce it on SOFII.

There is virtually nothing new in fundraising. It’s one of the reasons I spend so much time in archives, hunting around for historical examples of how people used to raise money for charity. I learn a huge amount that I can implement – with a few twists – in today’s fundraising environment. I’ve even compiled an online archive of hundreds of old charity newspaper and magazine ads going back hundreds of years that illustrates the fact that best practice rarely changes.

But I was fascinated to discover that way back in the Middle Ages, the Cistercian monks in Austria actually taught fundraising as part of a formal course.

This was around about 1350, when Edward III was on the throne in England. At that time, European monasteries were education centres where students were sent to be trained to become administrators for kings and nobles.

Though pretty powerful, local rulers were often short of cash, so part of the instruction was how to coax voluntary donations from the richer members of the populous.

A handbook was produced which is partially reproduced in Fundraising Techniques and Case Histories, a fundraising book from the 1960s written by E. Hereward Phillips (not a relation that I’m aware of).

A plan for an appeal letter was included that presented the ideal structure for inclusion in a medieval direct mail pack. It detailed the five key elements of a letter. Translated from Latin, it sounds a bit ‘Harry Potteresque’, but it’s still a pretty good starting point for a fundraiser today.

Salutation. Give greetings and praise. Make tactful recognition of the reader’s rank and virtues.

Exordium. An introduction where you lead into the subject of the letter.

Narration. Where you set the stage with a description of the problem you are attempting to resolve.

Petition. Now you detail what you want the reader to do, described as the ‘supplication’.

Conclusion. Bring the letter to a graceful end with a form of ‘perotation’ to describe the impact of the gift in a way that will inspire passion and enthusiasm.

I’d probably shift my ‘supplication’ further up the page, but as you’ll see in the example at the end of the post, fundraising letters were not that long back in the 1350s. Apart from that, I think it answers most of the donor needs we recognise today.

But the monks didn’t stop there. They identified some of the reasons why people give to charity too, which shows that little has changed over the last 700 years. They included the following:

  • Being generous to avoid ridicule
  • The obligation of the wealthy to give
  • By giving you receive joy
  • To be kind is better than being a beast
  • Do as you would be done by
  • A little help works wonders
  • Feed the starving person
  • To give is a noble instinct.

They also produced a few specimen appeal letters written by a ‘fictional’ student in Paris to his rich uncle, a venerable archdeacon. Each letter shows how different approaches are required to reflect the position and needs of the potential donor. This one was used to illustrate ‘It is the obligation of the wealthy to give’ and might offer a hint or two for mid-level fundraisers:

Most upright in life and upright in all dealings, salutations to my most honourable master with my deepest respects.
Oh fortunate businessman! Oh noble merchant! Oh much admired financier! The Kingdom of Heaven could be compared to your estate, for it could be so easily transformed into eternal wealth.
Truly there is nothing more miserable than the miserable poverty of the scholars. Among these I am to be most pitied, for I am overwhelmed by my labours, broken by misery, and sapped by the gnawing of harassing debts.
I therefore beg and beseech your laudable interest in such a worthy cause. I pray and implore you, let me, your loyal clerk in squalid misery, enjoy some benefit of your treasure, which neither thieves steal nor moths corrupt.’

It needs a boost of human interest in the form of a description of the labours the writer faces and more detail on what practices a 14th century debt collector might employ. But I like the recognition of the reader’s status and their power to make a real change in the life of the writer.

I’d also suggest it might be a little short. But with the cost of velum being what it was, you can understand why the writer kept it to the point.

About the author: Mark Phillips

Mark Phillips

Mark Phillips started fundraising for ActionAid UK in the late 1980s and later became head of fundraising at YMCA England. He set up Bluefrog in 1997 with one simple goal – to be the agency he would have wanted to employ. His approach to fundraising is based on understanding and answering donor needs. Mark shares his ideas and findings through his blog, queerideas.co.uk.

Related case studies or articles

Take a trip in SOFII’s time machine: the SOFII history project - introduction and contents

Welcome to the greatest collection of historical fundraising brilliance you'll ever find.

Read more

The SOFII history project part 1: treasures from fundraising’s history.

Welcome to part one of SOFII’s history project. Dive in to explore the best campaigns from antiquity to the 20th century!

Read more

Moses raises funds for the tabernacle – c. 1,500 BC

This is now the oldest exhibit on SOFII (and will be, until you tell us different). It's also a surprisingly instructive fundraising case history. If you look at the detailed notes it becomes quite clear that the prophet Moses was an accomplished fundraiser who both understood his audience and appreciated the nuances of his fundraising proposition and how it would be received.

Read more

The first ever major donor dinner – c. 970 BC

With a clear target, a list of major prospects, an inspirational lead gift and a fantastic end result, the only thing that's not 'state of the art' about this event is that it happened 3,000 years ago.

Read more

The early Christian Church: Paul the apostle motivates his church’s donors – c. 56 AD

This could be the first ever appeal for regular, committed donors. In the early days of the Christian church the missionary Paul asked his supporters in the city of Corinth to set aside a small portion of their income regularly, to sustain victims of a famine and then later to support good works generally.

Read more

The early Christian Church: St Paul’s letter to the Corinthians

This may not be the world’s earliest ever recorded mention of fundraising but it could well be the first ever example of a fundraising director exhorting his troops to achieve their targets. Or, do you know different?

Read more

Pliny the Younger and the first appeal for matching funds, c. 100 AD.

About 20 years after famously witnessing the eruption of Vesuvius that engulfed Pompeii, Pliny the Younger, perhaps the most generous benefactor of the Roman era, created a matching fund to help the parents in his home town to fund their school.

Read more

Eihei Dogen fundraising letter: from 1235

Sent in the year 1235, this may be the oldest fundraising letter on record. It is also an extraordinarily competent appeal that identifies the different types of people that the writer wishes to address.

Read more