Why do people give? The podcast with Lyndall Stein

In a cracking edition of his superb podcast, Mark Phillips continues his series by talking to the great Lyndall Stein.

Written by
Mark Phillips
Added
February 13, 2020

Lyndall is a remarkable fundraiser. Her experience includes setting up the UK fundraising operation for the African National Congress when Nelson Mandela was still in prison. She then went on to work for the Terrence Higgins Trust, when HIV and AIDS were still beyond treatment, before moving on to The Big Issue Foundation.

What makes this interview so special is that Lyndall repeatedly had to work without budget and with very little in the way of resources – no computers, no filing systems, no agency and no database. But what she achieved is amazing.

She shows how she identified her audience and used the fundamentals of direct marketing – through testing – to make her advertising as effective as possible whether it was ads on the front page of The Guardian or through developing mailing packs (with techniques that are still effective today).

When the ANC approached Sylvester Stein and his daughter, Lyndall, to help them raise money for the struggle against apartheid they didn’t – in her words - ‘know where to start’. They weren’t daunted and went on to raise a huge amount of money. The young Lyndall’s reward was to meet Nelson Mandela – and get a kiss too. Lucky thing.

Lyndall speaks of the importance of learning from the experience of others and sharing knowledge. And to that end she gives us her advice on use of photographs and the need to make sure that our language is right for our supporters (you can read more about her thoughts here).

We discuss offering donors choice. Whilst working for the ANC, Lyndall included tick boxes on her response devices so donors could choose how a gift should be used – schools, hospitals, or ‘wherever it was most needed’. As we see today when we use the same technique, many ticked the most needed box, but since the interview, I’ve learned that some donors added an extra box of their own ‘for AK47s’.

We speak about hate mail and how the advice her father gave her – ‘chuck it straight in the bin’ – is as relevant for today’s trolls, with their anonymous and abusive Twitter accounts – as it was then.

But what I found most valuable are Lyndall’s thoughts on what fundraising is good at and what it isn’t. It can raise money, but don’t think of it as a cheap route to boost PR or promote an ideology – even when you are part of a liberation movement.

And, of course, she shares her thoughts on why people give and we spend plenty of time talking about connection.

You can also listen and subscribe on iTunes here.

Note from SOFII: this podcast originally appeared on Mark’s blog here. Our thanks to him for letting us reproduce it here.

This is an appeal letter from Mendi Msimang. More details on this particular pack can be found by clicking on the image.
Page two of Mendi Msimang’s letter. You can find another approach to ANC’s fundraising by clicking on the image.
Page three of the Mendi Msimang letter.
Page four of the Mendi Msimang letter.

About the author: Mark Phillips

Mark Phillips

Mark Phillips started fundraising for ActionAid UK in the late 1980s and later became head of fundraising at YMCA England. He set up Bluefrog in 1997 with one simple goal – to be the agency he would have wanted to employ. His approach to fundraising is based on understanding and answering donor needs. Mark shares his ideas and findings through his blog, queerideas.co.uk.

Related case studies or articles

Why do people give? A podcast by Mark Phillips of Bluefrog Fundraising.

We’re delighted to bring you the first edition of a very special podcast: Why do people give? Hosted by Mark Phillips of agency Bluefrog Fundraising, episode one features celebrated fundraising legend Giles Pegram, CBE,  former fundraising director of the NSPCC.

Read more

How often in life do you have total satisfaction?

This remarkable article from Lyndall Stein that describes the fundraising campaign she and other volunteers organised for the African National Congress when South Africa was in the grip of apartheid.

Read more

My big mistakes – and what I learned

When Lyndall Stein’s article on the ANC first appeared on SOFII it prompted the comment: ‘This is a great piece! Wow, the power of fundraisers!’ However, one part of an ANC campaign had a serious flaw. Here Lyndall owns up to that mistake, and others, and tells SOFII users what she learned from them.

Read more

It’s the picture not the frame

‘When I saw the three-year-old Aylan Kurdi, I was petrified. [He] ... was lying lifeless face down in the surf, in his red t-shirt and dark blue shorts folded to his waist. The only thing I could do was to make his outcry heard.’ Nilufer Demir, photographer, on why she released the photo.

But was she right? Read Lyndall Stein on why we fundraisers shouldn’t shrink from the challenge of using powerful images to change the world.

Read more

CDE project 6 section 4: fear, flight and fight – turning pain into gain

Lyndall Stein explores the use of powerful images and words and how they can be key to reaching into a donor’s heart.

Read more

Following the fold

Lyndall Stein shows that you're never too old to learn some new tricks and passes on some fundraising tips for the young from the old.

Read more

A fundraiser’s alchemy: turning tears to gold

In this new article about her time with AIDS charity the Terrence Higgins Trust, Lyndall Stein says, ‘…I have learned that it is a privilege to be a fundraiser. When you are working on the toughest issues in the hardest times, you know that your blood, sweat and tears will be turned to gold, that your work will be meaningful, relevant and will matter…’

Read more