Garbage in, garbage out

News flash! A stupid nonprofit ad wins an award!

Written by
Jeff Brooks
Added
May 14, 2013

Well, almost. It was a student division of the D&AD awards (a UK advertising industry association).

Thanks to Queer Ideas for the tip and don’t miss Mark Phillip’s cogent discussion of this project.

Or watch it here on YouTube.

I realise it’s really not fair to label the work of students as ‘stupid’. What’s stupid about this is that it won an award judged, presumably, by professionals who should know better.

Further, it was an assignment that could hardly do otherwise than to produce stupid work. The challenge to students was to ‘present an idea that engages support for Oxfam by triggering shared values and concerns in a wide range of people’. There’s a brief with a lot more information, but the direction is no better.

The main problem here is the ‘wide range of people’. That's not an audience. It’s simply not possible to communicate effectively with everyone. In fact, the students who produced this ad solved that problem by aiming at themselves.

At least, I think that’s what they did. How else could you explain an attempt to stir people to compassion by parading a series of snarky, pissed-off potty-mouths who would rather do anything else than fight poverty? These kids seem to think fundraising is a bigger enemy than poverty itself.

In other words, this ad doesn’t have the faintest clue about the psychology behind charitable giving.


I’m sure the students who produced it learned a lot from the project. And that’s the main point for them. But the judges then told them their work was good, thus potentially setting them out on careers of more stupid nonprofit ads. They also signalled clearly to all the other students who entered their work, some of them quite good, that the stupid, snarky stuff is the gold standard.

So we can expect the plague to continue in the coming years. Shame on the D&AD judges.

Jeff Brook’s new book The Fundraiser’s Guide to Irresistible Communications will be reviewed on SOFII soon. Look out for it.

About the author: Jeff Brooks

Jeff Brooks

Jeff Brooks, creative director at TrueSense Marketing, has served the nonprofit community for more than 20 years, working as a writer and creative director on behalf of a variety of organisations, including CARE, Bible League International, World Vision, Feeding America, World Relief and dozens of urban rescue missions and Salvation Army divisions. He blogs at Future Fundraising Now, podcasts at Fundraising is Beautiful and is a columnist forFundraising Successmagazine. In previous careers, he's been an English teacher and a classical musician. He lives in Seattle in the USA.

Recent Articles

The A to Z of writing fundraising appeals: A to F

Writing a good appeal is a big undertaking and isn’t as easy as some may think. In this handy guide Blue Frog London’s Steve Lynch gives a handy alphabetical guide to the dos and don’ts of writing a fundraising appeal.

Read more

From the Mythsmashers: the myth of the ‘rational donor’.

In the first presentation from Mythsmashers, an I Wish I’d Thought of That (IWITOT)-inspired event that takes place every year down under, Alice Anwar of CARE Australia explores the myth of donor rationality and asks ‘Can the head and the heart ever be friends?’

Read more

Secrets of direct mail 3: how people read letters

How do potential donors react to direct mail letters? In part three of our series on the legendary Siegfried Vögele, we explain this important aspect of his approach.

Read more

SOFII presents: meet the fundraising myth-smashers

Over the coming weeks, SOFII will share the three winning presentations from Myth Smashers, Fundraising Institute Australia’s IWITOT-inspired event. These three young fundraisers each shine a light on dispiriting fundraising myths and show how they can be overcome.

Read more

Marie Burnett: she lived, laughed, loved and left a huge hole in our hearts

We are sad to announce the death of Marie Burnett, co-founder of SOFII, trustee, company secretary, honorary treasurer and voluntary editor in chief.

Read more

Also in Categories